Defense Officer in Charge Carlito Galvez Jr. said on Friday that the Philippine government “is aiming to achieve an optimal number and locations of the EDCA sites to maximize their coverage of the Philippine archipelago.”

“We understand the apprehensions expressed by our local chief executives about EDCA and our bilateral exercises. However, we must consider the volatile situation in which we operate and not view our country in isolation,” said Galvez.

“The Philippines straddles a crucial location in the Pacific, and we have seaboards to the north, south, east and west. All of these must be monitored and protected,” he added.

Last month, the DND announced the Philippine and US governments agreed to designate four new EDCA Agreed Locations. EDCA, along with the Visiting Forces Agreement, operationalizes the 1951 Philippine-US Mutual Defense Treaty (MDT).

The agreement will give US troops access to four more bases, with the aim of accelerating the full implementation of EDCA.

Ads by:
Memento Maxima Digital Marketing
@[email protected]
SPACE RESERVE FOR ADVERTISEMENT
.

 

Previously, both countries have designated five locations for the EDCA: the Antonio Bautista Air Base in Palawan, which is closest to the Kalayaan Island Group; Basa Air Base in Pampanga; Fort Magsaysay in Nueva Ecija, the country’s largest military camp; Benito Ebuen Air Base in Cebu in the Visayas and Lumbia Air Base in Cagayan de Oro City in Mindanao.

The DND has yet to name the locations of the new EDCA sites, saying it would be made public once all the necessary consultations, coordination, staff work and other requirements are completed or complied with. However, two sites in Cagayan, and one each in Palawan, Zambales, and Isabela have been mentioned.

While Cagayan Gov. Manuel Mamba said he was not keen on having an EDCA site in his province, his vice governor, Melvin Vargas Jr., was more calm in his opinion on the issue.

Vargas told The Manila Times in an interview earlier this week that any plans to establish two additional US military facilities in the province of Cagayan would require extensive public consultations.

Ads by:
Memento Maxima Digital Marketing
@[email protected]
SPACE RESERVE FOR ADVERTISEMENT
.

“Formality wise we are still waiting for the scheduled consultations that will happen in our province. Hopefully, different sectors will be invited. I will be one of those who will attend to be able to learn more about the plan,” he said.‘Long overdue’

Signed in 2014, EDCA’s implementation was delayed for various reasons, Galvez said.

“EDCA was met with legal challenges, but the Supreme Court eventually upheld its constitutionality in 2016. Coupled with other technical issues, which have since been resolved, and the restrictions brought by the pandemic, the implementation of the projects under EDCA was delayed for many years,” said Galvez.

“Thus, the identification of new sites for additional EDCA Agreed Locations is actually long overdue.”

Ads by:
Memento Maxima Digital Marketing
@[email protected]
SPACE RESERVE FOR ADVERTISEMENT
..

Galvez also emphasized that developing the nation’s defense capabilities through bilateral efforts such as EDCA with the US aims to build deterrence, and is not for engaging in war or interfering in the domestic affairs of other nations.

“The geopolitical situation is becoming more precarious by the day,” he said. “Our projects under EDCA and our other defense partnerships are not intended for aggression. We are not preparing for war, rather we are aiming to develop our defense capabilities against eventualities and threats to our security.”

The Defense chief added that the Philippines continues to forge ties not only with the US, but also with our friends, allies and like-minded nations.

Ads by:
Memento Maxima Digital Marketing
@[email protected]
SPACE RESERVE FOR ADVERTISEMENT
.

“While we are further deepening and seeking ways to modernize our long-standing alliance with the US, we are pursuing engagements with many other like-minded nations,” said Galvez. “We are hopeful for the continued support of the Filipino people in these endeavors.”

He said that projects under EDCA are geared toward enhancing the facility readiness of the Armed Forces of the Philippines (AFP) as part of its modernization efforts to speed up external defense development.Response to external threats

“As the Commander in Chief, President Ferdinand Marcos Jr. directed the AFP recently, we are shifting our focus towards territorial defense, especially in the West Philippine Sea,” Galvez said.

He noted that previous engagements and exercises by the country with its partners used to focus only on internal security operations.

“Now, we are eyeing to strengthen our abilities to respond to external threats that may arise along our border areas.”

Galvez further stressed that undertaking projects under EDCA is one of the DND and AFP’s various efforts to prepare for contingencies in the domestic and regional spheres. These include responding to natural disasters and calamities, evacuating Filipino citizens in the region whenever needed, undertaking search and rescue operations, and defending against invasion.

“The MDT is founded on the principle of peace and promotion of regional stability. These underpin our activities and projects under EDCA,” he said.”As a nation, we renounce war as a foreign policy. However, we are committed to exhaust all available means and the resources available to us to defend our national interests.”

Ads by:
Memento Maxima Digital Marketing
@[email protected]
SPACE RESERVE FOR ADVERTISEMENT
.

‘Potential military target’

International relations and law experts, however, warned of consequences with the expansion of EDCA which, although not publicly admitted they pointed out, was partly designed to counter Chinese aggression in the West Philippine Sea.

Dr. Melissa Loja, Philippine Judicial Academy lecturer and consultant at the Office of the Chief Justice, noted that a territory of a neutral state, such as the EDCA sites in various parts of the country which is the location of stockpiles of weapon systems of a “belligerent state such as the US, can be a legitimate military target of another belligerent state, such as China, North Korea, Russia, or Iran.”

Loja said this is under the Caroline test which is considered part of customary international law that was adopted in the military tribunals in the Nuremberg trials and which is now part of the law of warfare.

“That use and ownership can justify a belligerent state making an attack on an EDCA site in the Philippines where there are US weapon stockpiles,” she said.

Loja noted that under EDCA Article 4 Paragraph 1, the US has the “unmitigated right” to stockpile not just supplies for humanitarian aid but also military weapons. The agreement, however, makes clear that this material cannot include nuclear weapons.

Ads by:
Memento Maxima Digital Marketing
@[email protected]
SPACE RESERVE FOR ADVERTISEMENT
..

International law expert Sass Rogando Sasot, meanwhile, said that as to the claim that the Philippines will be a target if war occurs “this has long been a concern of Filipinos even when we negotiated for Philippine independence in the 1940s.”

“Additional EDCA sites will provide additional targeting challenges for China. What does this mean? This means that the conflict will be more complicated. Rather than China only targeting the US military bases in Guam and Okinawa, the Philippines will also be included. So, this is the truth on the issue and even the US media is talking about this,” said Sasot.

On the other hand, George Siy, director of the Integrated Development Studies Institute (IDSI), said what the EDCA expansion is actually doing is “undermining” the gains in a “more improved Philippine-China relations that was achieved under the previous administration of former president Rodrigo Duterte.

During the Duterte administration, the Wharton-educated Siy pointed out that China became the top bilateral partner of the Philippines.

He said the latest available data showed that in 2020, 27.2 percent of the Philippines’ total trade is with China which is roughly around $41.8 billion compared to the US which is just 10.9 percent or $16.5 billion during the same period.

Between 2016 and 2022, Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas data showed that firms from China and Hong Kong invested $1.7 billion in the Philippines, trailing only Japan but ahead of the US ($1.3 billion).

While Japan continues to lead in aggregate amounts, Chinese-based investors led in volume. From 2016 to 2018, there were 3,634 firms established with Chinese investors, far outranking new firms with Japanese (1,091) and US investors (1,317).

During this period Chinese investors led the launch of and subsequent growth in online gaming and on-site casinos as well as realizing strong returns in real estate, especially around the Metro Manila area.